Posted on 1-10-2002

GE Free NZ On Death Row
From AP (Alternative Press) (Photo shows Greenpeace activists locking on to
the Federal Pescadores anchored in Auckland Harbour)

Public Confidence in ERMA destroyed by decision on GE Cows and plans for
"Conditional Release". It is time for Government to reconsider a
Parliamentary Commissioner on Biotechnology to protect the public interest.
ERMA "put on notice" over foreseen contamination from 'Pharming' as New
Zealand animals become chemical bio-reactors.

ERMA's response to the Agresearch GE cow application GMD 2028 weakens New
Zealand's biosecurity and regulation of biotechnology. The decision is also
likely to be challenged in the courts. The decision fails to adequately
address basic issues of economic and environmental damage, alternative
research as suggested by the Royal Commission, scientific containment or
issues of culture and ethics. "The decision needs to be scrutinised, but it
seems that ERMA has capitulated to our overseas export-image." says Jon
Carapiet, spokesperson for GE-Free NZ in food and environment.commercial
interest over good science and the public interest. 'The alternatives
suggested by the Royal Commission are being ignored. The result is Big
business 1, community- imput Nil." In the light of this decision the
Government's review of ERMA must include action to build confidence in the
Authority amongst independent scientists and the public before it reaches
rockbottom.

ERMA's support for "a "Conditional release" category for GM products is a
concerning sign that the Authority are in denial of overseas problems with
GE release. "There is sufficient evidence available to show that GE
constructs spread unless kept contained. With Pharming now developing
-Containment to guarantee segregation from conventional production is the
only way to protect Public Health. "Are ERMA , or Life Sciences companies
like AgResearch pretending ignorance of the growing body of evidence as a
defence against Liability? There are legal exemptions for damage which is
'unforseen'. New applications of GE have concerned scientists and the wider
community putting ERMA on notice," says Mr Carapiet. "Development of
'Pharming' using GM animals or crops to produce medical-drugs makes it
vital that Zero threshold of GM-system contamination in food is achievable.
The Minister of Health also has responsibility to ensure this prevention of
a significant public health risk. "The public want ERMA to show WHY they
believe they can prevent GE contamination when all others failed."

"ERMA's pretence at managing risk is no more credible than a gambler at a
casino."

Jon Carapiet 09 815 3370